Paired t test as a block design

Section of Analysis of variance, part of Statistical inference

Paired t test as a block design

Type Section
Taught in Analysis of variance
Part Statistical inference

Two tyre types, A and B, are fitted one each to five cars, and the tread left after 10 000 km is measured.

Car 1 2 3 4 5
Type A 10.6 9.8 12.3 9.7 8.8
Type B 10.2 9.4 11.8 9.1 8.3
Difference 0.4 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.5

Wear depends heavily on the car and the driver, so this is a randomised block design with 5 blocks and 2 treatments. Under that model the within-car difference D_i=Y_{i1}-Y_{i2}=\tau_1-\tau_2+\varepsilon_{i1}-\varepsilon_{i2} is \operatorname{N}(\tau_1-\tau_2,\ 2\sigma^2), independently across cars, and the car effect has cancelled. Testing \tau_1=\tau_2 is a one-sample t test on the differences. Their mean is 0.48 and standard deviation 0.0837, so

t=\frac{0.48}{0.0837/\sqrt5}=12.8

on 4 degrees of freedom, with two-sided p-value 0.0002. The tyres differ in wear. The block F test gives F=164.6=12.8^2, the same test.

The completely randomised design is the several-group version of the two-sample t test. The block design is the several-treatment version of the paired t test.

Key idea

Compare the variance of the group means with the variance inside the groups. Under equal means the ratio is an F statistic. Blocking pulls a known source of variation out of the error before that comparison is made.

A Bonferroni comparison and a worked haemoglobin table are in Analysis of variance examples.

Used in

See also

One-way analysis of variance · ANOVA sum of squares decomposition · ANOVA F distribution · Contrast · Tukey intervals · Randomised block design · Between and within · One-factor analysis of variance

Glossary and index